Sous Vide Steak with Cowboy Butter – Amazing 2-Hour Recipe

The first time I made sous vide steak with cowboy butter, it wasn’t for a special occasion—it was a regular Tuesday. I had this thick cowboy ribeye in the fridge and figured it was the perfect night to test out something bold. I seasoned the steak with garlic, salt, pepper, and rosemary, sealed it up, and let it soak in a 129°F water bath for two hours. When I pulled it out, that sous vide steak with cowboy butter plan kicked into full gear. The texture was unreal—tender, juicy, and just begging for flavor.

That’s when the cowboy butter came out. A garlicky, lemony, buttery mix I whipped up while the sous vide steak cooked. Once I got a good sear in a hot cast iron skillet, I spooned that cowboy butter over the top, watching it melt into every crevice. Honestly, I didn’t even wait to plate it. That first bite of sous vide steak with cowboy butter changed the way I cook steak forever.

Growing up in Florida, I always loved bright flavors. But learning how to make sous vide steak with cowboy butter shifted everything. It made beef less intimidating. Big cuts like cowboy steaks were no longer a risk. With sous vide steak, I got edge-to-edge doneness and a reliable, rich finish every time. Add cowboy butter to that equation, and it’s not just steak—it’s a flavor experience.

This recipe quickly became a go-to. Whether I’m cooking for guests or just treating myself, sous vide steak with cowboy butter always delivers. The buttery richness pairs perfectly with the juicy steak, and the best part? It’s surprisingly easy. The water bath does all the work, and you just finish it with a quick sear and a generous spoonful of cowboy butter.

If you’re loving the idea of buttery, perfectly cooked beef, try our zero-stress sous vide steak with cowboy butter method or explore more ideas like the medium-rare sous vide striploin. You’ll never look at steak the same way again.

Print

Ideal Temp and Time for 2-Inch Cowboy Steak

When cooking a 2-inch-thick sous vide steak with cowboy butter, your goal is simple: even doneness and unbeatable tenderness. Set your sous vide circulator to 129°F for medium-rare, the ideal balance of juicy texture and bold flavor. For a slightly firmer sous vide steak with cowboy butter, go with 135°F for medium. Keep your cowboy steak in the water bath for 2 hours—the magic number that lets muscle fibers break down while still preserving the natural texture of your sous vide steak with cowboy butter.

So why exactly 2 hours? For thick cuts like cowboy ribeye, this is the gold standard. A longer cook time—say 3 to 4 hours—might make your sous vide steak with cowboy butter a bit more tender, but if your steak is already well-marbled, that extra time isn’t required. The 2-hour mark hits the sweet spot: your sous vide steak with cowboy butter cooks to temperature edge to edge without any mushy texture or over-softening.

Precision is the reason so many home cooks fall in love with sous vide steak with cowboy butter. It takes the guesswork out of steak nights. You don’t have to worry about undercooking or overcooking—the sous vide method makes your steak consistent every time. Once you add cowboy butter after the final sear, it’s an explosion of flavor and texture.

For more consistency in your sous vide steak with cowboy butter, try patting the steak completely dry before the sear. That crust you get when butter hits the hot skillet? It’s what dreams are made of.

Want to compare how different cuts behave? This ribeye time guide covers all the details for thick steaks. Or check out this other sous vide steak with cowboy butter recipe variation for more inspiration.

Searing with Butter: The Final Touch

Searing matters. After sous vide, pat the steak dry and heat a cast-iron pan until it’s smoking hot. Add 2 Tbsp of olive oil and sear each side for 30 seconds. Then comes the magic: drop in 1 Tbsp of butter, baste, and sear each side for another 30 seconds. This not only builds flavor but gives you that golden crust you want.

Use a grill press or tongs to press the steak down, making sure every part contacts the pan. Don’t skip the sides—give them 15–30 seconds too.

Finish by resting the steak for 10 minutes before slicing. That gives the juices time to settle—no more dry steaks.

Want more bold butter flavor? You might enjoy our garlic herb butter steak or the indulgent balsamic glaze variation.

What’s in Cowboy Butter—and Why It Works

Cowboy butter is like the bold, flavorful sidekick every sous vide steak with cowboy butter needs. This isn’t your average compound butter—it’s a garlicky, herby, zesty spread that takes rich cuts of meat to a whole new level. When paired with sous vide steak with cowboy butter, the flavors are unbeatable. The butter combines softened butter, minced garlic, lemon juice, chopped parsley, Dijon mustard, crushed red pepper flakes, paprika, and sometimes a touch of cayenne for heat. Want to experiment? Add in chives or thyme to elevate your sous vide steak with cowboy butter even further.

What makes cowboy butter so perfect for sous vide steak with cowboy butter is contrast. Sous vide gives you precision—tender, juicy, edge-to-edge medium-rare steak. Cowboy butter gives you punch. It brings the acidity, the kick, the aromatic herbs that balance the richness of the meat. Once your sous vide steak with cowboy butter is seared to perfection, spooning this butter over the top lets it melt into every crevice, creating an experience that’s both savory and bright.

The best part? Cowboy butter can be made ahead of time. Whip it up while your sous vide steak with cowboy butter is cooking and store it in the fridge for later. Form it into a log with parchment paper, slice it into rounds, and you’ve got instant flavor bombs ready to drop on your next sous vide steak with cowboy butter.

It’s not just for ribeye. Try cowboy butter on sous vide tri-tip, flat iron, even filet mignon—it pairs beautifully with any sous vide steak with cowboy butter variation. Once you try it, you’ll want to use it every time you cook steak. And if you’re building a go-to rotation, sous vide steak with cowboy butter will earn a top spot fast.

How to Serve and Slice Like a Pro

Once your sous vide steak with cowboy butter is rested, it’s time for the final step: slicing and serving. Letting your steak rest for 10 minutes after searing is key—it locks in all those delicious juices that sous vide created. Now grab a sharp knife and cut against the grain. This helps preserve the tenderness you worked so hard to achieve with your sous vide steak with cowboy butter.

Cowboy steak has a bone-in structure, so start by slicing around the bone. Then cut the meat into thick, juicy strips. Each slice of sous vide steak with cowboy butter should be tender, rich, and ready for that buttery drizzle.

Presentation matters—especially with sous vide steak with cowboy butter. Fan the slices on a wooden cutting board or rustic platter. Spoon warm cowboy butter right over the top so it melts into the grooves of the meat. Add a sprinkle of finishing salt and a sprig of rosemary for that upscale, steakhouse look. The aroma alone will turn heads.

What to serve with sous vide steak with cowboy butter? Keep it simple. Roasted potatoes, grilled asparagus, or garlic green beans all complement the richness. Pro tip: cowboy butter isn’t just for steak. Spoon it over your sides and let those flavors tie the whole plate together.

If you’re in the mood for more rich, beefy mains, check out our reverse-seared prime rib—it’s a great partner to cowboy butter—or our garlic butter sous vide steak. Both follow the same winning formula: precision, flavor, and unforgettable results. But trust us—nothing satisfies quite like a perfectly sliced sous vide steak with cowboy butter straight from your kitchen.

Don’t Make These Steak Mistakes

Even though sous vide steak with cowboy butter is one of the easiest, most reliable ways to cook a steak, there are still a few common mistakes that can trip you up. The first big one? Skipping the sear. Your steak might be perfectly cooked on the inside, but without that caramelized crust, your sous vide steak with cowboy butter will lack contrast in texture—and that golden exterior is where the real flavor magic happens.

Another misstep: not drying your steak thoroughly. After the water bath, excess surface moisture can cause steaming in the pan instead of searing. If you want that crust to develop properly on your sous vide steak with cowboy butter, grab paper towels and pat it dry until completely moisture-free. It’s a small step, but it makes a massive difference.

Then there’s searing too long. You only need 60 to 90 seconds per side. Over-searing can char the butter and make your sous vide steak with cowboy butter taste bitter instead of buttery and rich. Always use high heat, a smoking-hot pan, and move fast.

And don’t make the rookie mistake of slicing too early. After searing, let your sous vide steak with cowboy butter rest for 10 minutes. This helps the juices redistribute instead of running out, giving you a juicy, flavorful cut from edge to edge.

Need help troubleshooting your sous vide steak with cowboy butter results? Check out our guide on can you overcook sous vide steak or learn how to finish it under the broiler. Both are great backups when you’re chasing steak perfection at home.

Pro Tips to Make It Even Better

Want restaurant-level results at home? Try these upgrades:

• Grill press or cast iron weight: Helps achieve an even crust on thick steaks like cowboy cuts.
• Fresh herbs in the sous vide bag: Rosemary, thyme, or crushed garlic can subtly infuse flavor.
• Make cowboy butter ahead: The flavors deepen as it sits. You can even freeze it in portions.
• Olive oil before sealing: Lightly coat the steak with oil and seasoning before vacuum sealing for a deeper flavor base.

For extra buttery inspiration, try this compound butter prime rib or learn how to sous vide steak with butter directly.

Conclusion: Why This Cowboy Steak Deserves a Spot in Your Rotation

When it comes to flavor, texture, and consistency, sous vide steak with cowboy butter is nearly unbeatable. The sous vide method offers precision that no other technique can match—giving you perfect doneness edge to edge, every time. Pair that with the bold, zesty richness of cowboy butter, and you’ve got a show-stopping combination. Whether you’re cooking for a weekend crowd or just treating yourself to something indulgent on a weeknight, sous vide steak with cowboy butter delivers a steakhouse-quality experience right in your own kitchen.

This isn’t just a recipe—it’s a confidence builder. Sous vide steak with cowboy butter teaches you how to take control of timing, temperature, and flavor. Once you’ve mastered the basic method, it becomes a canvas. You can switch out the herbs, play with spice levels in your cowboy butter, or try the same process on different cuts like tri-tip or striploin. Every variation builds on the foundation of what makes sous vide steak with cowboy butter so reliable and flavorful.

Ready to expand your sous vide lineup? If you loved the tenderness and punchy finish of sous vide steak with cowboy butter, don’t stop here. Try our juicy prime rib with horseradish cream or the flavor-packed garlic butter balsamic sous vide steak. Both recipes carry that same promise of precision and bold finish—but you’ll probably find yourself coming back to sous vide steak with cowboy butter again and again.

Because once you taste it, regular steak just doesn’t hit the same.

Join us on Facebook and Pinterest for even more delicious recipe ideas!

FAQs

Can you sous vide a cowboy steak?
Yes! Cowboy steak is ideal for sous vide thanks to its thickness and marbling. A 2-inch cut cooked at 129°F for 2 hours comes out tender, juicy, and evenly cooked.

Does Gordon Ramsay cook steak with butter?
Absolutely. Ramsay often finishes steaks in a hot pan with butter, garlic, and herbs to add richness and a golden crust—just like we do after sous vide.

Can I use butter instead of oil to cook a steak?
Butter alone has a lower smoke point and can burn easily. Use high-heat oil (like olive oil) to start the sear, then add butter at the end for flavor.

Why not to use butter on steak?
You can, but don’t sear solely in butter. It burns quickly at high temps. Instead, combine oil for searing and butter at the end for basting.

Does cooking a steak longer in sous vide make it more tender?
Yes, to a point. While 2 hours is great for tenderness, you can go longer for an even softer texture—but avoid exceeding 4–5 hours for ribeye.

Do chefs cook steak in butter?
Yes, especially during the final stages of cooking. Butter adds flavor, and when basted over hot steak, it helps develop a delicious crust.

Should you put olive oil on steak before sous vide?
A light coat of olive oil helps seasoning stick and adds richness. It’s optional but recommended—just don’t overdo it.